Cayuga County, NY Property Taxes (2026)

Cayuga County owners pay a median of $3,747 a year on a median home value of $164,200, an effective rate of 2.28%. That's the 24th-highest rate of 62 New York counties with Census data, above the New York county median of 2.18%.

Updated October 2026 · Data: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates (2019–2023)

Is your Cayuga appraisal too high?

We compare your value to recent Cayuga County sales and show you in about a minute whether a grievance is worth it.

  • Free check
  • No credit card

Effective tax rate

2.28%

24th highest of 62 in NY

Median annual bill

$3,747

~$312/month

Median home value

$164,200

New York county median

2.18%

Effective rate

What a protest could save you in Cayuga County

Enter the market value from your appraisal notice. We apply Cayuga County's 2.28% effective rate and a 10–15% reduction, the typical range for successful protests.

$
Est. annual tax
$3,744
Savings at 10–15% off
$374–$562
Check my actual assessment →

Cayuga County vs. New York vs. U.S. property tax rates

Cayuga County2.28%
New York county median2.18%
U.S. county median0.84%

Key stat: Cayuga County's effective property tax rate is 2.28%, vs. 2.18% for the median New York county and 0.84% for the median U.S. county. It ranks 24th of 62 in New York. Effective rate = median tax bill ÷ median home value, so it already reflects typical exemptions. (Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates (2019–2023))

How to grievance your property taxes in Cayuga County

  1. 1

    Review your assessment notice

    Check the assessed value from the Cayuga County or Town Assessor. Compare it to recent sales of similar homes nearby.

  2. 2

    File your grievance before the deadline

    The Cayuga County deadline is Varies by municipality. Missing it means waiting until the next assessment year.

  3. 3

    Gather evidence

    Recent comparable sales, photos of condition issues, repair estimates or an independent appraisal.

  4. 4

    Present your case

    Submit evidence or attend a hearing with the County or Town Assessor.

  5. 5

    Get your decision

    If you win, your assessed value and bill go down. On a $3,747 bill, 10–15% off is $375–$562 a year.

Want help with it?

TaxDrop builds your case from comparable sales data.

Check my assessment

Property tax exemptions in New York

New York homeowners may qualify for exemptions that reduce taxable value. Check with the Cayuga County or Town Assessor for amounts.

Homestead exemption

For your primary residence. Reduces the value used to calculate your bill.

Senior / over-65

Many states add an exemption or freeze for owners 65 and older.

Disability

For homeowners with qualifying disabilities, often similar to the over-65 benefit.

Veterans

Disabled veterans may get partial or full exemptions depending on rating.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the property tax rate in Cayuga County, New York?
The median effective property tax rate in Cayuga County is 2.28%: a median annual bill of $3,747 on a median home value of $164,200. That's the 24th-highest rate of 62 New York counties with Census data. Your own rate depends on which city, school district and special districts you're in. Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates (2019–2023).
How much are property taxes in Cayuga County?
The median Cayuga County property tax bill is $3,747 a year, about $312 a month, compared with a New York county median of $3,968.
What is the deadline to grievance property taxes in Cayuga County?
The deadline to grievance in Cayuga County is Varies by municipality. Missing it means waiting until the next assessment cycle.
Is Cayuga County a high property tax area?
Cayuga County's 2.28% effective rate is above the New York county median of 2.18% and above the U.S. county median of 0.84%. That's the 24th-highest rate of 62 New York counties with Census data.
Can TaxDrop help lower my Cayuga County property taxes?
TaxDrop analyzes your property against local comparable sales and helps you grievance your assessment.

Property taxes in nearby counties

Onondaga County

Rate: 2.59%

Median bill: $4,805

Seneca County

Rate: 2.29%

Median bill: $3,267

Wayne County

Rate: 2.55%

Median bill: $4,168

Oswego County

Rate: 2.58%

Median bill: $3,595

Yates County

Rate: 1.92%

Median bill: $3,417

Cortland County

Rate: 2.65%

Median bill: $4,184

Ontario County

Rate: 2.20%

Median bill: $4,460

Tompkins County

Rate: 2.35%

Median bill: $6,374

← All 62 New York counties

Stop overpaying on property taxes

See in about a minute whether your Cayuga value looks too high.

Check my assessment — free