TaxDrop
Start My Protest

Carroll County, Indiana Property Taxes (2026)

Carroll County homeowners pay a median property tax of $954/year on a median home value of $167,700 — an effective rate of 0.57%, which is below the national median of 1.02%. Carroll County has a population of approximately 20,443.

Appeal Your Carroll County Property Taxes with TaxDropCheck Your Tax Rate — Free Calculator

Effective Tax Rate

0.57%

Lower than the Indiana median of 1.00%

Median Home Value

$167,700

Annual Tax Bill

$954

~$80/month

Est. Annual Savings

$143

If reduced by 15%

Free Tax Check

Carroll County, Indiana Property Tax Calculator

Enter your address to instantly see if you're overpaying on property taxes. Our tool compares your assessed value against recent comparable sales in Carroll County to estimate your potential savings.

  • Takes less than 2 minutes
  • Uses real Carroll County comparable sales data
  • 100% free — no credit card required
Check Your Property Tax Rate →

Average Annual Savings

$143

Estimated savings for Carroll County homeowners

Property Tax Rates: Carroll County vs. Indiana vs. National

Carroll County0.57%
Indiana Median1.00%
National Median1.02%

Key stat: The effective property tax rate in Carroll County, Indiana is 0.57%, compared to the Indiana median of 1.00% and the national median of 1.02%. (Source: U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 5-Year Estimates)

How Carroll County Compares Across Indiana

See where Carroll County's tax metrics fall relative to all 92 Indiana counties.

Tax Rate Distribution

Percentile distribution across all Indiana counties

10th

1.00%

25th

1.00%

Median

1.00%

75th

1.00%

90th

1.00%

Home Value Distribution

Percentile distribution across all Indiana counties

10th

$122,330

25th

$143,825

Median

$171,400

75th

$205,425

90th

$236,540

Tax Bill Distribution

Percentile distribution across all Indiana counties

10th

$789

25th

$895

Median

$1,106

75th

$1,359

90th

$1,719

Carroll County County Assessor Information

Carroll County County Assessor

Assessing Authority

Carroll County Assessor

Appeal Deadline

June 15 or 45 days after notice

Indiana appeal filing deadline

State

Indiana

How to appeal

Let TaxDrop handle it for you →

How to Appeal Your Property Taxes in Carroll County

If you own property in Carroll County, you have the legal right to appeal your assessed value. Here is the step-by-step process:

1

Review your assessment notice

Check the assessed value from the Carroll County Assessor. Compare it to recent sales of similar homes in your area.

2

File your appeal before the deadline

The Indiana deadline is June 15 or 45 days after notice. Missing this deadline means waiting until the next assessment year.

3

Gather supporting evidence

Compile recent comparable sales, photos of property condition issues, independent appraisals, or any factors that reduce your home's value.

4

Present your case

Attend a hearing or submit your evidence to the County Assessor. Present clear data showing your assessed value is too high.

5

Receive your decision

If successful, your assessed value and tax bill will be reduced. With a median bill of $954, even a 10-15% reduction means $95-$143 in annual savings.

Skip the hassle — let TaxDrop handle it

TaxDrop's licensed consultants analyze your property, build your case with comparable sales data, and represent you through the entire appeal process. You pay nothing unless we save you $500 or more.

Start Your Carroll County Appeal →Free Tax Rate Calculator

Property Tax Exemptions in Indiana

Indiana homeowners may qualify for exemptions that reduce their taxable value. Common exemptions include:

Homestead Exemption

Available to primary residence owners. Reduces the assessed value used to calculate your tax bill.

Senior/Over-65 Exemption

Additional exemption for homeowners age 65+. May include a tax ceiling that freezes your bill.

Disability Exemption

For homeowners with qualifying disabilities. Similar benefits to the over-65 exemption.

Veteran Exemption

Disabled veterans may receive partial or full exemptions depending on disability rating.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the property tax rate in Carroll County, Indiana?
The median effective property tax rate in Carroll County, Indiana is 0.57%. On a home valued at $167,700, the median annual property tax bill is $954. Source: U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2026.
How much are property taxes in Carroll County?
The median annual property tax bill in Carroll County is $954, which works out to approximately $80/month. This is based on the median home value of $167,700 and an effective tax rate of 0.57%.
How do I appeal my property taxes in Carroll County?
To appeal your property taxes in Carroll County, Indiana, you need to file with the Carroll County Assessor before the deadline of June 15 or 45 days after notice. You'll need evidence that your assessed value exceeds your property's market value, such as recent comparable sales. TaxDrop can handle this entire process for you — you pay nothing unless we save you $500 or more.
Is Carroll County a high property tax area?
Carroll County's effective tax rate of 0.57% is below the national median of 1.02%. It's below the Indiana median of 1.00%.
What is the deadline to appeal property taxes in Indiana?
The deadline to appeal property taxes in Indiana is June 15 or 45 days after notice. It's important to file before this deadline — missing it means waiting until the next assessment cycle. TaxDrop monitors deadlines and files on your behalf to ensure you never miss the window.
Can TaxDrop help lower my Carroll County property taxes?
Yes. TaxDrop helps homeowners in Carroll County, Indiana appeal their property tax assessments. We analyze your property, compare it against local comparable sales, and handle the entire appeal process. Our fee is 25% of your savings — and if we don't save you at least $500, you pay nothing.

Nearby Counties

Benton County

Rate: 0.76%

Tax bill: $1,024

Blackford County

Rate: 0.81%

Tax bill: $779

Boone County

Rate: 0.80%

Tax bill: $2,725

Brown County

Rate: 0.47%

Tax bill: $1,141

Cass County

Rate: 0.69%

Tax bill: $824

Clark County

Rate: 0.74%

Tax bill: $1,566

Clay County

Rate: 0.46%

Tax bill: $589

Clinton County

Rate: 0.62%

Tax bill: $979

← View all 92 Indiana counties

Stop overpaying on property taxes

30-60% of properties are over-assessed, but only 5% of homeowners challenge their bill. TaxDrop makes it easy to fight back. No upfront cost. No fee if we save you less than $500.

Check Your Savings